C1 porównanie opinii

Przeczytaj cztery opinie i przy każdym pytaniu wybierz, którego autora dotyczy.

Towers in Historic Cities

Four writers give their views on building tall towers in historic city centres. For each question, choose from the writers A–D.

A. A

Historic city centres are not infinitely adaptable. A single glass tower placed carelessly beside a medieval quarter can alter the character of a view that has survived for centuries, and once it is built there is no undoing it. Developers like to present their towers as the answer to the housing crisis, but look at who actually lives in them. Many of the flats are sold off-plan to overseas investors and stand empty for much of the year; they do nothing for the nurse or the bus driver who cannot afford to rent. Then there is the environmental cost. Tall buildings need vast quantities of steel and concrete, as well as lifts and pumps running day and night, so their carbon footprint per square metre is considerably higher than that of a modest block. And at their feet one usually finds a windswept plaza that people hurry across rather than linger in.

B. B

I have nothing against tall buildings as such, but I believe they belong in business districts, not on the edge of a cathedral close. The skyline of a historic city is a shared inheritance, and a tower that dominates it imposes one developer's ambitions on everyone. Where I differ from some fellow sceptics is on housing. Our cities need hundreds of thousands of new homes, and in a crowded centre the only realistic place to put many of them is upwards; refusing all towers simply pushes the problem elsewhere. I am under no illusions about their environmental record, however. The energy that goes into producing and maintaining a skyscraper is enormous, and claims of green credentials usually rest on a few solar panels and a roof garden. Nor have I seen many towers that improve the street. Most present a blank lobby and a gust of wind to passers-by.

C. C

Every age has resented the buildings of the next. The spires and domes that we now regard as the essence of the historic skyline were themselves bold intrusions in their day, and I suspect our grandchildren will be fond of some of today's towers. A city that is not allowed to change becomes a museum. There are practical arguments too. Towers can house large numbers of people on very little land, which is exactly what crowded cities require, and putting residents within walking distance of their work and of public transport saves far more energy over a building's lifetime than it costs to construct. The common complaint that towers deaden the street seems to me to rest on poor examples from the 1960s. The best recent schemes have shops, cafés and public gardens at ground level, and the streets around them are busier than before.

D. D

My objection to tall buildings in historic centres is chiefly visual. A skyline is built up slowly over centuries, and it can be spoiled in the eighteen months it takes to put up a single tower. I am also unconvinced that towers are the solution to the shortage of homes. Terraces and mansion blocks of six or seven storeys can achieve densities just as high, and they are far cheaper to build and maintain. On the environment, I am rather more sympathetic: a compact city where people can walk to work is greener than one that sprawls into the countryside, and a well-designed tower can play a part in that. Nor do I accept that towers must be hostile at street level. Where architects have taken trouble with the ground floor, with arcades, markets and generous public space, the result can be livelier than the street it replaced.