C1 porównanie opinii

Przeczytaj cztery opinie i przy każdym pytaniu wybierz, którego autora dotyczy.

Tourists in Space

Four writers comment on commercial space tourism. For each question, choose from the writers A–D.

A. A

It is easy to sneer at billionaires taking ten-minute joyrides above the atmosphere, but I think the critics miss the bigger picture. Every flight helps drive down the cost of reaching space, and cheaper launches will eventually benefit the scientific missions and satellite services that we all rely on. I have also watched these flights capture the imagination of young people in a way that government space programmes rarely manage nowadays. I do worry about the emissions; rocket exhaust released high in the atmosphere has an effect out of all proportion to its volume, and that needs serious study. But I see no case for the state to restrict or penalise the industry while it is still finding its feet.

B. B

I have reported on the space industry for over a decade. Whatever its champions claim, space tourism is a luxury product for a tiny elite, and the idea that its benefits will trickle down to the rest of us is wishful thinking; the technology being developed is aimed at selling more seats, not at advancing science. Far from inspiring the public, the spectacle of the super-rich floating in zero gravity while the planet overheats has left many people cynical. The environmental cost is real: soot from rocket engines lingers in the upper atmosphere for years. At the very least, each flight should carry a substantial tax, set high enough to reflect that damage.

C. C

I have spent twenty years working on rocket engines, so I have watched the rise of space tourism from close quarters. Concern about the environmental impact of space tourism is, frankly, misplaced. Even on the most optimistic projections, the industry will burn a tiny fraction of the fuel consumed by commercial aviation in a single day. The real story is what these companies are achieving technically. Reusable rockets, developed largely with private money, have already cut launch costs dramatically, and scientists are among the main beneficiaries. And I have seen how a launch broadcast live can fire up a classroom of teenagers. I would leave the industry alone, beyond basic safety rules.

D. D

As an economist, I tend to look at space tourism as a market like any other. I am not opposed to wealthy people spending their money on a trip to the edge of space, and I see no reason for governments to stand in their way or to tax them specially for it. But we should be honest about what it is: an expensive thrill. Claims that it will deliver cheaper science or better satellites for everyone strike me as marketing; the engineering problems of a tourist capsule are not those of a research probe. The public, as far as I can tell, watches with mild indifference rather than wonder. My real reservation is environmental: soot from rocket launches accumulates in the stratosphere, and if flights become frequent, that could become a genuine problem.