Przeczytaj cztery opinie i przy każdym pytaniu wybierz, którego autora dotyczy.
The Future of Zoos
Four experts give their views on the role of zoos today. For each question, choose from the experts A–D.
A. A
Zoos like to present themselves as modern arks, and to some extent the claim is justified. Captive breeding has brought a handful of species, from the Arabian oryx to the California condor, back from the very edge of extinction, and that achievement deserves recognition. Where I part company with the industry is over its educational pretensions. Watch how most visitors actually behave: they drift from enclosure to enclosure, glance at the information boards and are in the café within the hour. There is little sign that they leave knowing more, or caring more, about biodiversity than when they arrived. Nor can I accept that elephants, polar bears or great apes, animals that roam across vast territories in the wild, can lead anything resembling a full life behind a fence. I would like to see zoos as we know them wound down over a generation, with their breeding work handed to specialist centres closed to the public.
B. B
Critics of zoos often seem to be arguing with the menageries of fifty years ago. The best modern zoos design enclosures around the behavioural needs of each species, and the animals in them show every sign of thriving: they breed readily, live longer than their wild relatives and display the full range of natural behaviour. The conservation record speaks for itself, too; several species exist today only because zoos kept breeding populations going. I would also defend zoos as places of learning. A child who has stood a metre from a gorilla is far more likely to care about rainforests than one who has only seen them on a screen. That said, zoos cannot carry on as they are. They should keep fewer species, chosen for their conservation value rather than their popularity with visitors, and channel much more of their income into protecting habitats in the wild.
C. C
There is no serious doubt that zoos have played a valuable role in conservation; without captive breeding, the list of extinct species would be considerably longer. But I am less convinced by the claim that a day at the zoo is educational. Surveys of visitors before and after a visit typically find only marginal changes in knowledge, and even those tend to fade within weeks. We must also be honest about welfare. Many smaller animals adapt well to captivity, but repetitive pacing and other signs of distress remain common among large carnivores, however generous their enclosures. My own view is that zoos should gradually evolve into sanctuaries, caring for animals that cannot be returned to the wild rather than acquiring new ones for display.
D. D
I have worked in zoos for most of my career, and I would love to be able to say that they are saving species. The truth is that only a small fraction of the animals in zoos belong to endangered species, and the number successfully returned to the wild is smaller still. Conservation is largely a justification invented after the fact. Where zoos do succeed is in sparking curiosity: I have seen too many young visitors go on to study biology to dismiss their educational impact. But I accept that some animals, the big wide-ranging species in particular, do not belong in captivity at all. The way forward, I believe, is for zoos to concentrate on a smaller number of species that genuinely benefit from captive breeding, and to spend far more on projects that protect wild habitats.