C1 porównanie opinii

Przeczytaj cztery opinie i przy każdym pytaniu wybierz, którego autora dotyczy.

The Four-Day Week

Four commentators discuss the idea of a four-day working week. For each question, choose from the commentators A–D.

A. A

The trial results that have generated so many headlines deserve a closer look. The companies taking part volunteered, which means they were the firms most confident that the scheme would work, and output was often measured by the companies themselves. I am not persuaded, on that basis, that a shorter week leaves productivity intact. What I do accept is that staff felt markedly better: lower burnout, fewer sick days, better sleep. Those gains are real and worth having. But the model has obvious limits. A hospital ward or a supermarket cannot simply close on Fridays; covering the fifth day means hiring more people, and many such employers could not afford that. Any move in this direction should be left to individual organisations, not imposed from above.

B. B

I have advised more than thirty companies on shorter working hours. Every serious trial I have examined shows the same pattern: output holds steady, or even rises, when hours fall. People waste less time when they know it is limited. I am more cautious about the claims for wellbeing. In several firms I have studied, employees squeezed five days' work into four and ended each week exhausted, so the extra day off was spent recovering rather than living. Done properly, though, the model can work in almost any sector, from manufacturing to care homes, provided rotas are designed carefully rather than everyone taking the same day off. I would not want governments to make it compulsory; it should spread because it works, not because it is required.

C. C

Few workplace ideas have spread as quickly in recent years as the four-day week. I have no doubt that most office-based firms can move to four days without losing output; the evidence on that point is now overwhelming. Nor is there much doubt about the benefits for employees, who consistently report less stress and more time for family and exercise. Where I think enthusiasts get carried away is in assuming that the model suits every industry. Where work depends on someone being physically present, in hospitals, shops or transport, a shorter week means either more staff or worse service, and neither is costless. For that reason I would leave the decision to employers and unions, sector by sector, rather than writing it into law.

D. D

I have followed this debate closely since the first large-scale trials began. The productivity case has been made convincingly: across dozens of trials, companies have achieved as much in four days as they previously did in five. I am less sure that staff are happier as a result; surveys after the first year show many reporting pressure to cram their workload into fewer hours. Even so, I believe the four-day week can and should become the norm across the whole economy, and that it will only do so if governments act. The five-day week itself was won through legislation, not by waiting for employers to volunteer, and there is no reason to expect a different path this time.