Przeczytaj cztery opinie i przy każdym pytaniu wybierz, którego autora dotyczy.
The Decline of Local News
Four journalists and media researchers discuss the decline of local newspapers. For each question, choose from the writers A–D.
A. A
When a town loses its newspaper, it loses more than a source of gossip and planning notices. It loses the reporter who sat through every council meeting and every court hearing, and with that reporter goes much of the scrutiny that keeps local officials honest. Studies in the United States have even linked newspaper closures to higher borrowing costs for local government, presumably because nobody is watching. Facebook groups are no substitute. They spread rumour as readily as fact, and nobody in them has the time, training or legal protection to investigate. It would be unfair to blame publishers for what has happened; classified advertising, which once paid for everything, simply migrated online. I have therefore come round, rather reluctantly, to the idea of public support, perhaps through a fund that newspapers of any political stripe could apply to, with strict safeguards for their independence.
B. B
Local journalism matters enormously; a community without it is a community whose institutions can behave badly in the dark. But I am wary of the idea that the state should pay for it. A newspaper funded by government money, however carefully administered, will always be vulnerable to the suspicion that it pulls its punches. And we should not overlook the new forms of local news emerging online, such as independent websites run by former reporters and community groups that livestream council meetings. Some of them do excellent work on a shoestring. We should also be honest about the industry's own failures. The big newspaper chains bought up titles across the country, sacked most of the journalists, filled the pages with press releases and celebrity stories and then expressed surprise when readers stopped buying.
C. C
I may be in a minority, but I think the decline of the local paper has been rather romanticised. Many of them were never fearless watchdogs; they relied heavily on advertising from local businesses and councils, and they were often reluctant to upset either. The suggestion that local democracy is crumbling because the weekly paper has closed seems to me overstated. Much of what those papers did is now done, and often done better, by neighbourhood forums, residents' associations and local blogs. Nor do I believe that taxpayers should be propping up a business model that has had its day. As for the reasons behind the decline, I see little point in blaming publishers. They faced a collapse in advertising revenue that no amount of good management could have prevented, and most did the best they could with a shrinking budget.
D. D
The disappearance of local reporters is one of the quietest crises of our time, and its consequences are far from trivial. Without them, decisions about schools, hospitals and planning are taken with almost no public scrutiny. Social media cannot fill the void; it is very good at circulating outrage and very bad at the slow, unglamorous business of checking facts. Yet I cannot support the idea of a public subsidy, which would place journalists in an uncomfortable relationship with the very authorities they are supposed to hold to account. Some of the wounds, moreover, were self-inflicted. Publishers chased online clicks with sensational headlines and slashed newsroom budgets to protect their profit margins, and in doing so they destroyed the very thing that made readers value a local paper.