C1 porównanie opinii

Przeczytaj cztery opinie i przy każdym pytaniu wybierz, którego autora dotyczy.

Street Art

Four writers give their views on street art and graffiti. For each question, choose from the writers A–D.

A. A

I know it is unfashionable to say so, but painting on someone else's wall without permission is vandalism, however accomplished the result. The owner of a shop shutter or a railway bridge did not ask for a stencil, and the cost of removing it falls on them. Some will point out, as if it were scandalous, that a famous artist's work can sell for a fortune once it has been cut out of the wall; that does not trouble me in the least, and if the owner profits from an unwanted image, so much the better for them. Nor am I persuaded that colourful walls are responsible for pushing out long-standing residents. Rents rise for all sorts of reasons, and murals have helped many run-down streets feel cared for. The sensible approach, surely, is for councils to offer artists legal walls and paid commissions. Several cities have done exactly that, and their streets are better for it.

B. B

Street art began as a way of claiming public space for people who had no other voice, and the fact that it is uninvited is part of its meaning. Treating every unauthorised piece as a crime misses that entirely. What dismays me is the way the market has moved in. Walls are now being removed with power tools and shipped to auction houses, and a form that was meant to be free and temporary has become one more luxury commodity. I also think we should be honest about who benefits when a neighbourhood becomes famous for its murals. Estate agents mention them in their adverts, rents climb, and before long the people who lived there can no longer afford to. Council-commissioned murals do not solve the problem either; they tend to be cheerful, inoffensive and almost indistinguishable from advertising.

C. C

To dismiss all unauthorised street art as vandalism is to ignore some of the most exciting visual work of the last fifty years. Of course a tag scrawled across a front door is a nuisance, but a thoughtful painting on a derelict wall can transform a street. I am relaxed about the art market's growing interest. If collectors want to buy work by street artists, and some of that money finds its way back to the artists themselves, I fail to see the harm. The claim that murals cause gentrification also seems to me to confuse cause and effect: neighbourhoods change for economic reasons, and art usually helps residents take pride in where they live. Councils that pay artists to decorate underpasses and blank walls are doing something worthwhile, and the best of these commissions are every bit as bold as the illegal work.

D. D

Much of what is dismissed as vandalism is better described as an unofficial public gallery, open to everyone and free of charge, and I would not want it policed out of existence. The real danger to street art comes not from the authorities but from its own success. Once a piece is cut from a wall and hung in a collector's living room, it loses the context that gave it meaning, and artists who chase sales risk losing their edge. I do not, however, believe that street art drives up property prices; deprived areas with lively walls stay deprived unless there is investment of a quite different kind, and the art at least brightens them. What I find disappointing are the official mural schemes now popular with councils. Everything has to be approved by a committee, and the results are usually safe, decorative and forgettable.