Przeczytaj cztery opinie i przy każdym pytaniu wybierz, którego autora dotyczy.
Public Money for the Arts
Four writers give their views on government funding for the arts. For each question, choose from the writers A–D.
A. A
When arts organisations plead for public money, they increasingly do so in the language of the Treasury: every pound invested, we are told, returns four to the local economy through tourism, restaurants and jobs. I see nothing wrong with that argument; the figures are real, and they help persuade ministers who might otherwise see the arts as a luxury. What concerns me more is where the money goes. A disproportionate share is spent within a few miles of the capital's theatres and galleries, while towns elsewhere have to make do with crumbs. I would also resist the growing demand that funded work should prove its worth by selling tickets, since some of the most valuable art finds only a small audience at first. If businesses are prepared to sponsor exhibitions or productions, I say good luck to them; a company logo in a programme is a small price to pay for work that would not otherwise happen.
B. B
Arts funding has become hostage to an economic argument that it can never win. Once you claim that a theatre deserves support because it generates spending in nearby cafés, you invite the obvious reply that a shopping centre would generate more. The arts should be funded because they matter in themselves, as education and health do, not because they are a clever investment. For the same reason, I do not believe success should be measured in ticket sales; an orchestra that plays only crowd-pleasers is failing in its purpose. I am less exercised than some by the concentration of funding in the capital: the great national companies tour widely and broadcast their work, so the whole country benefits. Where I would sound a warning is over corporate sponsorship. Sponsors expect something in return, and the pressure to avoid offending them, however subtle, gradually narrows what artists feel able to say.
C. C
Supporters of the arts are right to emphasise their economic value. Festivals, galleries and theatres bring in visitors, create jobs and give struggling town centres a reason to exist, and that is a perfectly legitimate reason for the state to support them. But with public money comes an obligation to the public. Too much funded work is made for a small circle of critics and fellow artists, and I see no reason why a company that consistently plays to half-empty houses should go on receiving grants year after year. Funding is also far too heavily concentrated in the capital; people in the north pay the same taxes and are entitled to the same opportunities. I am wary, though, of the idea that private sponsors can fill the gap. Companies choose causes that flatter their image, and organisations that depend on them soon learn to avoid anything controversial.
D. D
There is now solid evidence that the arts pay their way. Cultural tourism alone supports tens of thousands of jobs, and many towns that have invested in a gallery or a festival have seen their high streets revive as a result; ministers would be foolish to ignore that. I am less convinced by complaints that the capital receives too much. Its national institutions belong to everyone, they lend their collections to regional museums and they train the actors, musicians and technicians who later work all over the country. Nor do I think that funding should depend on box-office success. Experimental work rarely draws large crowds at the start, yet it is often where the future of an art form is shaped. Finally, I would like to see far more private support. In other countries, generous tax incentives have encouraged businesses and individuals to give, and the arts have flourished as a result.