C1 porównanie opinii

Przeczytaj cztery opinie i przy każdym pytaniu wybierz, którego autora dotyczy.

Phones in Schools

Four writers give their views on banning smartphones in schools. For each question, choose from the writers A–D.

A. A

The evidence from schools that have removed phones from the school day is now hard to ignore: concentration improves, lessons are interrupted less often and results, particularly for weaker pupils, tend to rise. I support a ban for those reasons. I would be careful, though, not to promise more than it can deliver. Cruel group chats and humiliating photos do not disappear when the school gates close; they simply move to the evening, when no teacher is around. I would also make an exception for teachers who use phones purposefully. A quick class poll, a recording of a pupil's spoken French or a photograph of a science experiment can enrich a lesson, and banning that seems perverse when many schools have no tablets of their own. Practically speaking, a ban is easy enough to run. Phones go into lockers or sealed pouches in the morning and come out at home time.

B. B

Politicians love a phone ban because it looks decisive, but the research behind it is thinner than they admit. The studies most often quoted compare schools that differ in many other ways, and when those differences are taken into account, the effect on exam results is small or disappears altogether. Where I think a ban does help is with pupils' wellbeing. Head teachers who have introduced one report fewer incidents of online bullying during the day and far more conversation in the playground, and that alone may justify it. I am unimpressed by the argument that phones are valuable learning tools; in practice they are used mainly for distraction, and anything worthwhile can be done on a school computer. Nor is enforcement as difficult as opponents suggest. Once a clear rule is in place and parents are on board, pupils adapt within weeks.

C. C

A phone in a teenager's pocket is a constant invitation to look away from the lesson, and the improvement in attention once phones are removed is something teachers notice within days; the research largely confirms their impression. I am less optimistic than some campaigners about bullying, however. Unkindness that takes place online is not caused by phones being in school, and pupils who are targeted find the messages waiting for them as soon as they switch on at four o'clock. As for so-called educational uses, I have yet to see a lesson that genuinely required a smartphone; most of what is claimed for them could be done with a pencil. My school has had a ban for three years, and it costs us almost nothing to run. Phones are handed in at registration and returned at the end of the day without any fuss.

D. D

Few teachers would deny that pupils concentrate better without a phone buzzing in their pocket, and the improvement in some schools' results after a ban has been striking. Removing phones also seems to give pupils a break from the social pressures of the internet; several schools report a sharp drop in online bullying during the school day. All the same, I have doubts about how a ban works in practice. Pupils simply bring in a second, older phone, staff spend hours confiscating devices and dealing with angry parents, and the rules are applied unevenly from one classroom to the next. It would also be a pity to lose the genuine benefits. Used well, phones let pupils record experiments, film their drama work and check a source instantly, and those are skills they will need in adult life.