Przeczytaj cztery opinie i przy każdym pytaniu wybierz, którego autora dotyczy.
Literary Prizes
Four writers and critics discuss the value of literary prizes. For each question, choose from the writers A–D.
A. A
Whatever one thinks of literary prizes, there is no denying their commercial clout. A place on a major shortlist can multiply a novel's sales several times over within weeks, and booksellers plan their autumn displays around the announcement. What troubles me is the pretence that the result is somehow objective. Five judges with different tastes, reading well over a hundred novels in a few months, will reach a verdict shaped as much by compromise and fatigue as by merit; a different panel would very likely choose a different winner. Nor are prizes always kind to the people who win them. I have watched more than one author freeze under the weight of expectation, unable to finish the next book because everyone is waiting for it. And year after year the shortlists favour the same kind of novel: serious, finely written and rather solemn. Comedy and genre fiction barely get a look in.
B. B
The commercial argument for prizes is weaker than it appears. Yes, the winner enjoys a surge in sales, but the figures for the rest of the shortlist are often modest, and much of the extra money flows to a handful of large publishers who already dominate the market. I would nevertheless defend the judging. Having sat on two panels myself, I can say that the discussions are rigorous and conscientious, and I would stand by the choices we made; it is rare for a winning book to be one that most serious readers consider weak. My reservations lie elsewhere. Winning can be a mixed blessing for a writer, bringing a year of interviews and festivals that leaves little time or energy for writing. And the books that reach the shortlist tend to be cut from the same cloth: ambitious literary novels about weighty themes. A brilliant crime novel stands almost no chance.
C. C
I have heard all the complaints about literary prizes, and few of them persuade me. For a start, they get people reading. Every year, thousands of readers buy a shortlisted novel they would never otherwise have heard of, and many go on to explore the author's earlier work. The judging, too, is better than its critics claim. Panels are carefully balanced, and while one can always quarrel with an individual decision, the roll of past winners is, on the whole, a list of books that have lasted. As for the authors, I can think of several for whom a prize was transformative, giving them the money and confidence to give up a day job and write full time. Perhaps most encouragingly, recent shortlists have been far more varied than they used to be, finding room for experimental fiction, historical sagas and even the occasional thriller.
D. D
Anyone doubting the influence of prizes should look at the bestseller lists in the week after a winner is announced; few other events in the literary calendar can turn an obscure novel into a household name overnight. That influence is precisely why I worry about how the winners are chosen. Taste in fiction is personal, and the outcome often depends on which judge argues most forcefully on the final afternoon. It is something of a lottery, however dignified the ceremony. I also have sympathy for the winners themselves, who frequently find that the attention and the expectations that follow make the next book harder, not easier, to write. On one point, though, I think the critics are behind the times: the variety of books shortlisted in recent years has been striking, from comic novels to science fiction.