Przeczytaj cztery opinie i przy każdym pytaniu wybierz, którego autora dotyczy.
Exams or Coursework?
Four educationalists discuss how students should be assessed at the end of secondary school. For each question, choose from the writers A–D.
A. A
There has been a fashion in recent years for decrying examinations, but I remain convinced that they are the fairest form of assessment we have. Coursework completed at home inevitably reflects the resources of the household as much as the ability of the pupil: the child with an educated parent, a private tutor or, these days, a chatbot has an advantage that no moderator can detect. A well-set exam, by contrast, asks every candidate to show what they genuinely understand, under identical conditions. I am also sceptical about the much-discussed problem of exam stress. Some anxiety before an important test is normal, even useful, and learning to manage it is part of growing up; in my experience, the great majority of students cope perfectly well. I would therefore keep final examinations as the backbone of the system, with coursework confined to subjects such as art, where it is unavoidable.
B. B
I spent twenty years marking exam scripts, and I came to the conclusion that what they mostly reward is a good memory and a cool head on one particular morning. A student who understands a subject deeply but panics in the exam hall can end up with a lower grade than one who has simply memorised model answers. The pressure involved is considerable, too; the anxiety many teenagers feel during exam season is very real and should not be brushed aside. I am not naive about the alternative. Work done outside the classroom is vulnerable to all kinds of outside help, and the arrival of AI tools has made that problem far harder to police. The sensible answer, I think, is a balance: shorter exams alongside tasks completed in school under supervision, so that each form of assessment compensates for the weaknesses of the other.
C. C
Examinations have their defenders, but I have never been persuaded that a three-hour paper reveals much beyond a candidate's ability to recall information at speed. Real understanding shows itself in sustained work: an investigation designed and carried out over weeks, an essay drafted and redrafted. Unfortunately, that kind of work is also the easiest to outsource. Parents, older siblings and now software can all lend a hand, and there is no reliable way of telling. Contrary to what is often claimed, coursework is not the gentler option either. In my experience it stretches the pressure across two whole years, with a deadline looming almost every week, which many students find more exhausting than a few weeks of exams. My preference would be a combination of the two, so that neither the weaknesses of exams nor those of coursework dominate.
D. D
Much of the hostility to coursework rests on a misunderstanding. Teachers who have taught a pupil for two years know perfectly well what that pupil can produce, and work that has been completed with outside help usually stands out a mile; in any case, much coursework is now done in lessons, under the teacher's eye. I would not abolish exams, which do test whether students have mastered a subject and can apply what they know to unfamiliar problems. But we should be honest about what they cost. The weeks of revision and the sense that everything hangs on a single performance take a real toll on young people's mental health, as any school counsellor will confirm. A system that combined examinations with assessed work throughout the course would be both fairer and kinder.