Przeczytaj cztery opinie i przy każdym pytaniu wybierz, którego autora dotyczy.
Everyone's a Critic
Four writers discuss online reviews and the role of professional critics. For each question, choose from the writers A–D.
A. A
It is tempting to celebrate the online review as the democratisation of taste, and in one sense it is: there is no reason why a newspaper critic's opinion of a pizza should count for more than that of the family who eat there every Friday. The trouble lies in the system rather than the principle. Ratings are routinely inflated by fake praise and dragged down by competitors, and it is often impossible to tell which is which. Meanwhile, the professional critic is becoming an endangered species; newspapers have cut their arts pages, and few readers under forty could name a single reviewer. What worries me most is the damage done to small enterprises. A family restaurant can see its bookings collapse after a handful of furious one-star posts, sometimes written by people who never set foot in the place, and it has almost no way of answering back.
B. B
Online reviews have their uses, but I would not choose a hotel on the strength of them alone. Too many are written by friends of the owner, or by companies paid to produce them by the thousand, and the platforms seem in no great hurry to stop them. That is one reason why I think the professional critic remains indispensable. A reviewer who has seen hundreds of productions, and who knows the history of an art form, can explain why a play works or fails in a way that a star rating never could; taste may be personal, but judgement is learned. Readers seem to agree: the most respected critics still have a remarkable ability to fill or empty a theatre. As for businesses that complain about harsh customer reviews, I have limited sympathy. Being answerable to the people who pay you is no bad thing.
C. C
The anxiety about fake reviews is, I think, overstated. Individual posts may be unreliable, but when a restaurant has two thousand reviews, the occasional invention makes little difference, and the overall rating is a remarkably accurate guide. I do not share the view that professional criticism is dead, though. People still seek out a trusted voice for a film or a novel, and a rave from the right critic can make a career. Where I disagree with traditionalists is over the idea that one needs special training to have a valid opinion. Enjoying food or music does not require a degree, and ordinary audiences are often quicker than critics to spot what is fresh. My one real concern is the effect on small firms. A café run by two people simply cannot absorb a spiteful campaign of one-star posts in the way a chain can.
D. D
Anyone who has tried to choose a restaurant from online ratings knows how unreliable they can be. Whole review sites have been found to be riddled with entries bought in bulk, and genuine reviewers tend to write only when they are either delighted or furious. Still, I would not mourn the professional critic too much; their power was already fading long before the internet, and it is now largely confined to a few prestigious publications that most people never read. Nor do I think critics ever had a monopoly on good judgement. A reader who has loved crime novels for thirty years knows as much about them as any reviewer. As for the effect on business, reviews are simply part of the modern marketplace. Firms that treat their customers well generally come out ahead, and I see no reason to shield them from honest criticism.