C1 porównanie opinii

Przeczytaj cztery opinie i przy każdym pytaniu wybierz, którego autora dotyczy.

Competitive Sport in Schools

Four teachers and researchers give their views on sport in schools. For each question, choose from the writers A–D.

A. A

Schools have long assumed that competitive sport builds character, but I see little evidence for it. What I see instead is that a programme built around winning tends to reward children who are already strong and well coordinated, while the rest learn mainly that exercise is something at which they fail, and many of them give it up as soon as they can. The answer is not necessarily more hours of PE; the current allocation is adequate if it is used well. It is a broader menu: dance, climbing, yoga, cycling, activities in which children can measure progress against themselves rather than against classmates. Those are the habits most likely to last into adulthood.

B. B

I coached school teams for twenty years before becoming a head teacher. Learning to win graciously and lose without sulking is one of the most valuable lessons school can offer, and competitive sport teaches it better than anything else. I would like to see far more time given to it; two hours a week of PE is a scandalously small amount when childhood obesity is rising. That said, PE departments must be honest about how they treat their weakest pupils. Too often the least able are picked last, mocked and quietly humiliated, and they draw the conclusion that sport is not for them. I would not dilute the programme with fashionable alternatives, though. Football, netball, hockey and athletics have endured because they work.

C. C

As a researcher in child development, I have spent years observing how children respond to organised sport. Competition, properly managed, is good for children: it teaches resilience, teamwork and how to handle setbacks. I do not think the problem is the amount of time allocated to PE, which is reasonable in most schools; the problem is how narrowly that time is used. Children who do not shine at ball games tend to be discouraged early and abandon exercise in their teens. Offering activities such as dance, martial arts or orienteering would give far more pupils something they enjoy and are good at, and would keep them active long after they have left school.

D. D

I have taught PE in the same comprehensive school for most of my career. Few things in a school week teach as much as a competitive match: commitment, cooperation and how to recover from defeat. Unlike some of my colleagues, I believe these benefits extend to less athletic children too; learning to keep trying in a game you are losing is, if anything, more valuable for them than for the stars, and most of the struggling pupils I have taught relish the challenge. My frustration is that PE is constantly squeezed by exam subjects. It deserves at least twice its current share of the timetable. And I would keep the focus on team games, which deliver those lessons far better than solitary activities.