Przeczytaj cztery opinie i przy każdym pytaniu wybierz, którego autora dotyczy.
Art Made by Machines
Four commentators discuss images created with artificial intelligence. For each question, choose from the commentators A–D.
A. A
When a person spends hours refining instructions, selecting, rejecting and editing the results, I see no reason to deny that the outcome is art; photography faced exactly the same objection in the nineteenth century. What concerns me is the economic fallout. Illustrators who earn their living from book covers, advertising and magazine work are already losing commissions to software that costs a fraction of their fee, and many will not recover. It also troubles me that these systems were trained on millions of images taken without their creators' permission or payment. I am less exercised by the question of labelling; a good image is a good image, and audiences rarely care how a picture was made once they like it.
B. B
Art, as I understand it, is the expression of a human intention, and an image assembled statistically from millions of others has none. These pictures can be striking, but calling them art empties the word of meaning. I am not, however, as worried as some about illustrators. Clients who want something distinctive will continue to pay for a human hand, and the best practitioners have never been easy to replace. My objection is rather to the way the software was built, by absorbing artists' work without asking them, and to the confusion it is causing. Every AI-generated image in a public setting should be clearly identified as such, so that viewers know what they are looking at.
C. C
I teach illustration at an art college, so this debate is far from abstract for me. Whether we like it or not, AI-assisted images are art in the sense that matters: people make them, choose them and respond to them emotionally. But I fear for the professionals. Commercial illustration was never well paid, and when a publisher can produce an acceptable cover in seconds, a great many careers will quietly disappear. I find the outrage about training data harder to share. Every artist learns by studying and imitating others; a system that does the same on an enormous scale is doing something different in degree but not in kind. As for compulsory labels, I think they would be unenforceable and would soon be ignored.
D. D
As a gallery curator, I have watched these tools move from novelty to everyday use remarkably quickly. I have come round to the view that work produced with these tools can be genuine art, much as electronic music eventually earned its place alongside the orchestra. Predictions that illustrators will be wiped out strike me as exaggerated; every new technology has created as much work as it has destroyed, and many illustrators are already using AI to speed up their own process. What I cannot defend is the way the systems were trained, on artists' work used without consent. And I think audiences have a right to know: images made with AI should carry a clear label, particularly in news and advertising.