Przeczytaj teksty i przy każdym zdaniu wybierz, którego tekstu dotyczy.
Remembering and Forgetting: Four New Books
In which review are the following mentioned?
A. The Palace of Recall by Imogen Carter
Carter, a former memory champion, sets out to show that anyone can learn to memorise a shuffled deck of cards or a list of a hundred names. The techniques she describes, chiefly a method of her own for placing items along an imagined route through a familiar building, are explained with admirable clarity, and I found myself using them within days. Where the book falls short is in its larger claims. Carter suggests that such training improves memory in general, but the evidence she cites is thin, and she is curiously silent on a study by her former coach, Dr Helen Ward, which found that the benefits rarely extended beyond the specific tasks practised. An entertaining manual, then, but not the revolution it promises.
B. Erased by Dr Samuel Osei
Osei is a neuroscientist who studies forgetting, and his central argument is that we have it backwards: forgetting is not a failure of memory but an essential part of how it works. A brain that retained everything, he argues, would be swamped with irrelevant detail and unable to generalise. It is a provocative thesis, and Osei defends it with an impressive range of his own work, from experiments in his laboratory to interviews with people with exceptional autobiographical memory, some of whom find it more of a burden than a gift. The prose is occasionally dense, and readers without a scientific background may need to persevere, but the effort is well rewarded.
C. The Unreliable Witness by Clare Fenwick
Fenwick, a criminal barrister, was prompted to write this book by a case in which a man spent eleven years in prison on the strength of an eyewitness who was entirely sincere and entirely wrong. Drawing on the case and on her own years in court, she argues that memories can easily be distorted by leading questions, by later information and even by the act of recalling them. Her account of the case itself is gripping and genuinely moving. The later chapters, which propose reforms to police interviewing and courtroom procedure, are more uneven; some of her suggestions have already been adopted by the police in her own county, a fact she oddly fails to acknowledge.
D. Grandmother's Kitchen by Tomasz Wilk
Wilk's book is the only one here that is not, strictly speaking, about the science of memory. It is a memoir of caring for his grandmother through the final years of her dementia, interwoven with recipes she could still cook long after she had forgotten his name. It could easily have been unbearably sad, and parts of it are. But Wilk writes with such warmth and humour that the overall effect is uplifting. His observation that the body seems to remember things the mind has lost is not developed scientifically, and perhaps does not need to be. Of the four books, this is the one I expect to reread.