Przeczytaj teksty i przy każdym zdaniu wybierz, którego tekstu dotyczy.
Four New Biographies
In which review are the following mentioned?
A. Light Work by Helen Marsh
Edith Lowe took some of the most striking photographs of Victorian working life: women gutting herring on the quay, children asleep in a match factory, miners blinking in the daylight at the end of a shift. Yet for over a century, many of these images were credited to her husband, Frederick, in whose name they were exhibited and sold. Helen Marsh's biography sets the record straight, and does so convincingly, drawing on a box of Edith's notebooks that turned up in a house clearance only six years ago and that no previous writer has seen. These notebooks, full of technical notes and wry observations, give the book its liveliest passages. Marsh also traces how the false attribution survived for so long, largely because Frederick's family controlled the archive until the 1960s. My only reservation is one of proportion. At well over six hundred pages, the book follows every exhibition and every quarrel with a patience that some readers will not share, and a firmer editor could have removed a third of it without losing anything essential.
B. Silent Keys by Daniel Okoro
Lionel Baptiste was never famous, but for twenty years he was the pianist every jazz singer in London wanted beside them. Daniel Okoro is his grandson, and he says so on the first page, which is to his credit. Inevitably, though, the closeness shows. Okoro is quick to explain away Baptiste's long absences from his family and his habit of borrowing money he never repaid, and a more detached author would surely have pressed harder. Where the book excels is in its voices. Okoro spent three years tracking down musicians, club owners and former neighbours, many of them now in their nineties, and their recollections, quoted at length, form the heart of the book. The prose is plain and occasionally clumsy, but the material more than compensates. Several of these witnesses have since died, which gives it a value that goes well beyond its subject. Anyone interested in how the London music scene actually worked, rather than how it is usually romanticised, will find a great deal here.
C. The Long Ascent by Ingrid Solberg
Anton Weiss is remembered, if at all, as the reckless climber who abandoned his partner on a remote Himalayan peak in 1934. Solberg argues persuasively that this story, repeated in countless magazine articles, is largely invented. The surviving partner's own account, which she quotes in full, describes a joint decision taken in a blizzard, and she shows how the more dramatic version grew out of a single newspaper report written by someone who was never there. Readers hoping for a villain may be disappointed; Solberg's Weiss is stubborn and difficult, but no coward. Solberg is a climber herself, and her descriptions of ice, rock and altitude are some of the most gripping I have read; you can almost feel the cold. Yet this is not a book only for mountaineers. Its real subject is ambition and its price, and I would recommend it to anyone who has never set foot on a hill and has no intention of doing so.
D. A Life in Seeds by Mark Ellery
Clara Penrose travelled through South America in the 1880s collecting plants, many of which still grow in British gardens, but she left almost no letters and no diary. Ellery is admirably frank about this. Where the evidence runs out, he says so, and his occasional guesses about what she might have felt are clearly labelled as such, which is more than many biographers manage. Ellery writes clearly, if a little drily, and his account of how Penrose kept seeds alive on a six-week sea voyage is genuinely fascinating. Less successful is his decision to organise the book by plant rather than by date. Each chapter takes a species she introduced and moves backwards and forwards through her life from there, which sounds elegant but left me repeatedly unsure of where, or when, we were. A simple timeline at the back would have helped enormously. Even so, this is a careful and humane portrait of a woman who deserved one long ago.