C1 czytanie ze zrozumieniem

Przeczytaj tekst i wybierz odpowiedź zgodną z jego treścią.

The Lure of Free

A few years ago, a large bookshop opened near my office and announced that the first two hundred customers through the door would receive a free canvas bag. I joined the queue at half past eight, stood in a light drizzle for forty minutes and walked away with my prize: a beige bag bearing the shop's logo, of a kind I already owned in some quantity. When I showed it to a colleague, she asked, with what I felt was unnecessary precision, how much I earned an hour. By her calculation, the bag had cost me roughly what I would have paid for a decent pair of shoes. It had not occurred to me to think of it in those terms. It had been free, and that, apparently, had been enough.

I was, it turns out, behaving exactly as economists would predict, or rather as they would have predicted had they not spent a century assuming that people weigh costs and benefits sensibly. In one frequently cited experiment, participants were offered a choice between an expensive, high-quality chocolate and a cheap, ordinary one, each at a modest price. Most chose the better chocolate. When both prices were reduced by the same small amount, so that the ordinary chocolate now cost nothing, the majority switched to it, even though the difference between the two prices was exactly what it had been before. Nothing about the relative value of the chocolates had changed. Only the word attached to one of them had.

The usual explanation is that a price of zero removes the possibility of loss. Anything we pay for might disappoint us, and the prospect of regret, however slight, hangs over every purchase. A free item carries no such risk, so we grasp it with a relief out of all proportion to its worth. This seems to me persuasive as far as it goes, but I am not sure it goes far enough. A gift is also a gesture, and part of what attracts us to free things is the faint sense of having been singled out, of being the object of someone's generosity. That the generosity is a marketing strategy does not seem to diminish its effect.

Businesses, needless to say, have absorbed these lessons rather faster than the rest of us. The online shop that offers free delivery on orders above a certain sum knows perfectly well that many customers will add an item they do not need in order to avoid a charge smaller than the item's price. The app that costs nothing to download is paid for, often handsomely, with our attention and our personal data. The word 'free' is doing a great deal of work in such arrangements, and most of it, I suspect, on behalf of the seller.

It would be easy to conclude from all this that free is merely a trap for the unwary, but that would be too cynical. When a number of national museums stopped charging for entry some years ago, visitor numbers rose sharply, and the increase was not confined to people who would have paid anyway. Families who had never set foot in such places began to visit, partly because there was nothing to lose if the children got bored after twenty minutes. The same logic that leads us to queue for an unwanted bag can also lower the barriers that keep people out of libraries, parks and galleries. The problem is not free itself. It is our tendency to forget that the cost of something rarely vanishes; it is simply moved somewhere we are less likely to look.

I still have the bag, as it happens. It has carried groceries, library books and, on one occasion, a sleeping kitten, and I like to think that by now it has more than earned its place in the cupboard. My colleague, when I put this argument to her recently, said that my arithmetic was as unreliable as ever and that I had merely found a more elaborate way of justifying a wet morning. She may have a point. But I notice that she has borrowed it twice.